Square and Level
All posts

Cedar, vinyl, composite or pine: how to choose

By The Square and Level team

Fence and deck builders

October 8, 2026

Sample boards of cedar, pine, composite and vinyl on a workbench next to a carpenter's square and a level.

The first question on almost every estimate is the same: what should we build it out of? There's no single right answer — it comes down to budget, how much upkeep you're willing to do, and the look you want. Here's the short version.

Pressure-treated pine: the budget pick

Pine is the most affordable option and it's strong — it's what nearly every deck frame is built from. The trade-off is upkeep: it can check and twist as it dries, and it needs sealing every couple of years to last.

Cedar: the classic look

Cedar naturally resists rot and insects and has a warm color that weathers to silver if you leave it alone. It costs more than pine, but it's more stable and it's the go-to for good-looking privacy fences.

Vinyl and composite: set it and forget it

Vinyl fences and composite decks cost more up front, but they never need paint, stain or sealer. If you'd rather spend weekends using your yard than maintaining it, they usually pay for themselves over time.

Still not sure? Start an estimate and we'll price your project in more than one material, so you can compare side by side.

Ready for a fence, deck or floor done right?

Tell us about your project; we'll take it from there.